Virgin has a more satin finish while the WnW shade is more shimmery and slightly lighter. Out of the three shades, I would say these two are the least alike, but they are still pretty similar.
These shades are very similar, but the WnW is slightly more bronze colored, while Smog is slightly more gold. They both have shimmery finishes.
These shades are literally identical! There is absolutely no difference between the two colors in any way.
Even though “Virgin” and “Smog” aren’t 100% identical to the two Wet n’ Wild shades, they are super close, and once applied, you can’t tell the difference. Overall, I would definitely consider these three eyeshadows dupes for the ones in the Naked 1 Palette. I highly recommend this inexpensive trio to anyone who is interested in these 3 specific Urban Decay shades.